The Truth About Condo Investing in York Region Right Now: What the Numbers Actually Say
I have a lot of conversations about condo investment in York Region, and I have noticed two distinct camps. The first camp says condos are a terrible investment right now, supply is too high, rents are down, and you should stay away. The second camp says nothing has changed, real estate always goes up, just buy something.
Both of those positions are too simple. The truth is more nuanced, more interesting, and frankly more useful if you are seriously considering whether a condo purchase in Richmond Hill, Thornhill, or Vaughan makes sense as part of your financial picture.
Let me give you the honest version.
I am Heidi Shiraz, REALTOR and Mortgage Agent with Century 21 Heritage Group in Richmond Hill. I work in this market every day. Here is what I am actually seeing.
The Current State of the York Region Condo Market
The condo market in York Region has been the softest segment of the real estate market since mid 2023. Here is why, and what it means:
• New construction deliveries from projects that were pre-sold during the 2021 and 2022 boom are now arriving on the market. Many of these units have investors who bought at peak prices and are now listing at or near those prices into a market where rents have softened from their 2022 and 2023 peaks.
• Rental vacancy rates in York Region have risen compared to historic lows. In 2022, finding a tenant for a one bedroom condo in Richmond Hill within days of listing was routine. Today, landlords are offering one month free rent or absorbing lease-up periods of three to six weeks.
• The average resale condo price in York Region has declined from its peak, with one bedroom units along the Yonge Street corridor selling in the $530,000 to $620,000 range and two bedroom units ranging from $700,000 to $850,000 depending on building quality and suite size.
• Days on market for resale condos in York Region is running 35 to 55 days on average, compared to under 15 days during the peak market. This gives buyers significant time to do proper due diligence.
In plain language: the condo market in York Region is a buyers market. That does not automatically make it a good time to buy, but it does mean the conditions for finding value are better than they have been in years.
The Investment Case: Where It Works and Where It Does Not
Where Condo Investing Works in York Region Right Now
For a long term investor with a five to ten year horizon and the financial capacity to carry some negative cash flow in the early years, specific segments of the York Region condo market present genuine opportunity. Here is the profile of a purchase that makes sense:
• A resale unit in a well managed building, not a pre-construction assignment or a new delivery from an investor who overpaid. Resale units below replacement cost are where the value is right now.
• A building with strong reserve funds, low monthly fee increases over recent years, and no major special assessments pending. This requires a careful review of the status certificate, which I always recommend having a real estate lawyer review before you firm up any condo purchase.
• A location with genuine long term demand drivers. Along the Yonge Street corridor in Richmond Hill, the planned Yonge North Subway Extension from Finch northward through to Richmond Hill Centre represents a transformative transit investment that will materially increase the value of transit adjacent properties over the next decade. Buying well located units near future station areas at today's soft prices is a strategy with a clear long term logic.
• A unit with a layout that rents well. Two bedroom units consistently outperform one bedroom units in long term rental demand in York Region because they attract families and couples who stay longer and take better care of the space. One bedroom plus den units are a reasonable middle option.
Where Condo Investing Does Not Work Right Now
If your investment thesis depends on positive cash flow from day one, the math in York Region is very difficult in 2026. Here is a realistic example:
A two bedroom resale condo in a Yonge Street building in Richmond Hill at $780,000 with 20 percent down ($156,000) leaves a mortgage of $624,000. At a five year fixed rate of 4.75 percent on a 25 year amortization, your monthly mortgage payment is approximately $3,530. Add monthly condo fees of $650 and property tax of approximately $375 per month, and your total monthly carrying cost is roughly $4,555. A realistic rental income for that unit in today's market is $2,600 to $2,900 per month. The monthly shortfall is approximately $1,600 to $1,900 before any maintenance costs.
That is a significant cash carry. For investors who need the property to pay for itself immediately, this does not work. For investors who have the capacity to carry that cost as part of a long term wealth building strategy and who believe in the transit led appreciation thesis for the Yonge corridor, it is a different calculation.
The Subway Extension: Why Location Matters More Than Usual Right Now
The Yonge North Subway Extension is not a rumour or a distant proposal. It is a funded, approved transit infrastructure project that will bring TTC subway service northward along Yonge Street from Finch into York Region. The planned stations include Clark, Royal Orchard, Bayview, and Richmond Hill Centre, with a target completion timeline in the early 2030s.
Historically in Toronto and across the GTA, properties within walking distance of new subway stations have appreciated significantly as completion approaches and then again after opening. The Richmond Hill Centre area around Yonge Street and Highway 7 is the most logical focal point for this appreciation in York Region.
Condominiums in this area that are purchased at today's soft prices and held for seven to ten years are positioned to benefit from both the general appreciation of the broader market and the specific transit premium that subway access historically delivers.
This is not a guaranteed outcome. Real estate involves risk. But it is a rational, evidence-based investment thesis, and it is one I discuss openly with investor clients who are looking at this market seriously.
What About Pre-Construction? Is It Worth Considering?
Pre-construction condo investments in York Region need to be approached with more caution right now than at any point in the last decade. Here is why:
• Builder prices for pre-construction units in York Region do not fully reflect the current resale market correction. You may be paying above current resale value for a unit that will not deliver for two or three years.
• Occupancy costs during the period between occupancy and registration can be significant and are often underestimated by first time investor buyers.
• Developers in a slower market occasionally delay projects, reduce finishing quality from what was shown in the model suite, or substitute specifications. These risks require careful review of the purchase agreement by a real estate lawyer before signing.
I am not saying pre-construction is always the wrong choice. But in the current market, well selected resale units in established buildings offer more predictability and often better value than new pre-construction launches.
The Mortgage Side of Condo Investing
As a Mortgage Agent, I want to flag a few things that are specific to investment property financing that first time investors sometimes miss:
• Investment properties require a minimum 20 percent down payment. No mortgage default insurance is available for investment properties, which means you need to qualify for the full conventional mortgage amount.
• Lenders use 50 to 80 percent of your projected rental income when calculating your mortgage qualification. The rest of the carrying cost must be supported by your personal income.
• If you already have a primary residence mortgage, your total debt service ratios will be assessed across both mortgages. Some buyers who qualify easily for their primary home are surprised to find their investment property qualification is more restricted.
• Interest on a mortgage for an investment property is a deductible business expense in Canada, which changes the after-tax carrying cost calculation meaningfully. Speak with your accountant about how this applies to your specific situation.
I offer a free investment property mortgage review that gives you a clear picture of what you can borrow, what it will cost monthly, and what rental income you need to make the numbers work. It is a conversation worth having before you start touring units.
My Bottom Line for Condo Investors in November 2026
The York Region condo market is not the slam dunk it felt like in 2021. But for the right investor, with the right property, the right financial capacity, and a genuine long term horizon, specific opportunities exist right now that will not be available once rates drop and competition returns.
The key is being selective. Not every building, not every unit, and not every price. A careful analysis of the status certificate, the building financials, the neighbourhood trajectory, and the rental demand specific to that location is what separates a good condo investment from an expensive lesson.
I do this analysis with investor clients as part of the buying process. If you are serious about condo investing in York Region, I would welcome the opportunity to walk you through the numbers on specific properties.
Interested in Condo Investing in York Region? Call or text Heidi Shiraz: 416-270-4789Email: heidi.shiraz@century21.caWebsite: heidishiraz.com Century 21 Heritage Group Ltd., Richmond Hill, Ontario Free Investment Property Consultation. No Obligation. REALTOR and Mortgage Agent. One Conversation Covers Both.